Part 2
BY COL. E. H. C. CAVINS.
THE INDIAN OCCUPANCY-THE MIAMIS AND THE PIANKESHAWS-OTHER INDIAN
TRIBES-CESSION TREATIES-EFFORTS OF CATHOLIC MISSIONARIES-THE
MOUND-BUILDERS-THEIR BONES AND OTHER REMAINS-A PRE-HISTORIC
FORTIFICATION-FIRST WHITE MAN IN GREENE COUNTY-ABORIGINAL CUSTOMS-INDIAN
MURDERS-CONSPIRACIES-REMOVAL OF THE INDIANS WEST-THE MOUNDS AT
WORTHINGTON-BURIAL VAULT -SECTION OF THE MOUNDS-A CHARNEL HOUSE-CRANIAL
MEASUREMENTS-THE JAPANESE IDOL-CHEMICAL ANALYSIS-COPPER AXES,ETC., ETC.
PRIOR to the year 1767, the land embraced in Greene County, with a large
portion of the State of Indiana, belonged to a tribe of Indians called
the Piankeshews. This people was one of the Algonquin tribes, and was
one of the Miami , confederacy. The Miami confed- eracy was formed early
in the seventeenth century by the various tribes of Indians occupying
Ohio, Indiana, a part of Illinois and a part of Michigan. The object of
the confederacy was for the purpose of repelling the invasions of the
Iroquois or Five Nations, a very powerful combination of warlike
Indians, who being pressed toward the setting sun by the advance of
civilization, in turn pressed westward the weaker tribes of Indians.
Originally, so far as history or tradition gives any account, the whole
of Indiana was owned and occupied by the Twigtwees or Miamis, the Weas
and the Piankeshaws. At a later date, there were other tribes, called
permitted tribes, viz. : Delawares, or Leno Lenape, as they were
originally called, Pottawatomies, Shawnees, Kickapoos, with a few
Wyandots and Senecas. The Wyandots and Senecas seem to have had so
little claim upon the land that they were never required to sign any
treaty. The Pottawatomies seem to have acquired their interest by
conquest, or rather by pushing the Miamis back from the Northwest toward
the interior of the State, but they never claimed any interest in Greene
County.
THE DELAWARES.
The Delawares made a treaty with the Piankeshaws in 1767, by which they
came into possession of a large part of Central Indiana, including the
White River country as far south as the Lower Fork of White River, but
to make the title perfect it was conRidered necessary to make a separate
treaty with the Miamis. The Delaware Indians called White River
Opeco-me-cah. The Miamis at that time claimed the northern part of the
territory embraced in the treaty, and the Piankeshaws the southern part.
Greene County was in the part 'claimed by the Piankeshaws at that time.
In the treaty between the Piankeshaws and Delawares, it was only a
permissive possession that was given to the Delawares. These two tribes,
together with the Weas, were, and continued to be, on friendly terms
with each other, and all of them occupied the territory embraced in
Greene County, from the date of the treaty among themselves until they
were finally removed from the State. From some cause unknown to the
writer, the Piankeshaws never ceded to the United States any land north
of a line beginning at the mouth of Turtle Creek in Sullivan County, and
running in a direct line to Orleans, now in Orange County. But we trust
that the present owners of the land north of this line will not become
alarmed at the discovery of this breach or broken link in the chain of
their title.
THE CESSION TREATIES.
There were three treaties with the Indians, embracing the land in Greene
County. The first two were made on the 30th day of September, 1809, at
Fort Wayne with the Delawares and Miamis, and the last was made on the
26th day of October, 1809, at Vincennes with the Weas. Gen. William H.
Harrison, who was afterward President of the United States, was the
Commissioner who made these treaties, and it seems that he regarded it
as necessary to make it with these three tribes, but not necessary to
make a treaty with the Piankeshaws.
MISSIONARY WORK AMONG THE INDIANS.
After the settlement at Vincennes by the whites, the Piankeshaws seem to
have drifted toward that point, and near that place were their principal
villages and headquarters. They readily took upon themselves the vices
of their white neighbors, but did not seem to be impressed with their
virtues. They would patiently listen to the Catholic priests who tried
to impress upon them their mode of worship, and would quietly answer
them by as earnest an effort to get the Catholic priests to adopt the
Indian worship of the great spirit. One redeeming trait in their
character was developed at the beginning of the revolutionary war, and
that was, they were the first of the Western tribes of Indians to take
sides with the patriot cause against the English, and were soon followed
by the other tribes of the Miami confederacy.
AN EARLIER RACE.
Prior to the year 1810, no white man resided within the borders of
Greene County. Only straggling or strolling bands of Indians invaded the
territory. They seemed for many years preceding that time to have had no
permanent home here, but passed through on war and hunting excursions.
On many of the hills, and in many of the valleys and on many of the
plains they have left specimens of their rude and clumsy axes, made of
stone, and their nicely formed arrow heads made of flint. These mementos
of another age and of former inhabitants are found to this day. There
seems to be no place in the county specially noted for their rallies or
congregation in large numbers. No field has been made a scene of
carnage; no habitation has been made desolate by their fierce,
unrelenting tomahawk; or at least history or tradition have given us no
information of such events. In Section 8, Township 6 north, Range 5
west, there are clearly defined indications of lines of fortifications,
embracing about one-quarter of a mile. When they were made, or for what
purpose, is lost in the vista of time. Possibly in the ages past—before
the discovery of America—unrelenting war swept over that part of Greene
County, and possibly a regular siege was enacted at that place in that
day. In the northeast
corner of Richland Township, near what is called Sleath's Mill, there is
a large rock, which was used by the Indians as a lookout. The rude steps
cut by them for the purpose of enabling their sentinels to ascend to the
point of the look-out are still visible to any person whose curiosity
leads him to the place. At Fair-play, there has been found several
specimens of pottery of an ancient and rather crude type. Across the
river from Fairplay, after the great flood of 1875, there were found a
great many pieces of pottery, some of which had impressed ornaments on
them. These pieces bore evidence in themselves that they were of another
age, and they were washed out of the ground, over which large timber had
been growing a few years before. On the ridge coming up to the lower
Richland bridge, there was an Indian village, but deserted before any
white man set his foot upon Greene County soil. At Worthington quite a
number of Indian relics have been found in excavating—axes, arrow heads,
charms, earthen ware and many other curiosities, and among them two
copper tomahawks.
THE FIRST WHITE VISITORS.
In the year 1813, a party of white men visited the territory now known
as Greene County. They resided at Vincennes, then known as the Old Post.
They came on a hunting expedition, more for novelty, curiosity and
enjoyment, than for any other reason. They started out from Vincennes in
a pirogue or boat, went down the Wabash River to the mouth of White
River, and up White River to the fork, and thence up the West Fork to a
point above the mouth of Richland Creek, and landed on the east side of
the river south of Bloomfield. They spent several days in that locality,
hunting. At the time of this excursion, a part of the old Indian burying
ground near their landing was comparatively now. The Indian burying
ground was on the farm since known as the Warnick farm. In an early day,
it was a common thing for the boys from Bloomfield to dig up the
skeletons of these dead Indians. Perhaps they were induced to dig into
these graves from an idea that generally prevailed in those days that
the property of Indians was buried with them. While it was common to
turn up skulls and other no valuable discovery was ever made, except
that a gun human bones, barrel was found in one of the graves. Nearly
all traces of this ancient burying ground have disappeared through lapse
of time. The 'stalwart frame of many an Indian savage, whose war cry and
tomahawk sent terror to the hearts of many an innocent victim, has
doubtless returned to dust, and now forms a part of the soil of Greene
County. Many of the earliest settlers did not get over the deep and
abiding hatred they pustained toward the Indians, and especially those
whose relatives had been cruelly and wantonly murdered by them. After
the treaty of peace had been made between the whites and Indians,
occasionally an Indian would be found dead from a gun shot wound.
Several were killed in Greene County, one of whom was at a place a short
distance below the mouth of Richland Creek, on the east side of the
river, in a ravine running up from the river, on what is known as the
Lester farm. It was near the old Indian village, and was a wicked and
unprovoked murder. It was in the year 1810, while the Government survey
of land was being made.
AN UNPROVOKED MURDER.
An Indian had shot a deer in the ravine and was dressing it. -A hunter
by name of Smothers, who was employed by the surveying party to furnish
them with meat, was in the immediate vicinity, and when he heard the
crack of the Indian's rifle, he at once understood the situation.
Stealthily the white hunter stole upon his unsuspecting victim, and at
the crack of his rifle the Indian fell, and in a few minutes expired.
His body was concealed in the ravine 'and covered with stones, and
doubtless his decomposed bones are there now, unless washed into the
river. At that time the Government surveying party were encamped near
the southwest corner of Section 2, in Township 6 north, of Range 5 west.
When they learned of this murder, they were fearful that the Indians
would find their murdered companion, and they abandoned that camp, and
never blazed the line dividing Sections 2 and 11, so as to throw the
Indians off their trail, should they appear in that locality and seek to
avenge themselves. At that time there was an Indian trail passing up
White River from Owl Prairie, and the trail crossed Richland Creek near
the place where the lower bridge is built.
OTHER DEATHS.
Another Indian was killed in that locality in 1818. He was getting honey
from a tree, and while in the tree was shot by a white man. This was on
a narrow neck of land now known as the cut off, a short distance below
the mouth of Richland Creek. In the latter part of the year 1819, a
transient white man by the name of Osborn came to the settlement on
Plummer Cieek, and, while hunting, shot a Shawnee Indian, who was also
'hunting. The Indian at the time be was shot was sitting on a log, not
expecting any danger. This occurred at a place about one mile southwest
of Mineral City. After this man shot the Indian, he wont to Eli
Faucett's cabin. There was snow on the ground at the time, and it was
believed that he went to Mr. Faucett's in order to make the Indians, if
they should find that one of their number had been killed, believe it to
have been done by Mr. Faucett. The only settlers in that immediate
locality at that time was Col. Levi Fellows, Norman W. Pearce, Eli
Faucett and their families, and two or three hired hands. These
settlers, when they found out about the murder, compelled the murderer
to bury the dead Indian, and conceal his gun, and then required him to
leave the settlement, and that was the last that was ever heard of him.
There were no courts at that time nearer than Washington, in Daviess
County. About the same year and probably the summer following, an Indian
was killed by a white man at the mouth of Doan's Creek, only on the
opposite side of the river. A band of Indians were at that time on their
way to ayestern reservation, and encamped for the night on the west side
of the river. One of them went to the river to get a drink or after a
pail of water, and was shot from the east side, and fell into the river.
INDIAN CONSPIRACIES.
Notwithstanding the treaties that were made with the Indians for the
purchase of the territory embraced in Greene County, and other portions
ies, and especially among the tribes' or parts of tribes who were not
represented in the treaties. Prominent among the disaffected and
dissatisfied Indians were the celebrated. Tecumseh and his brother the
Prophet. Tecumseh was a Shawnee, and his tribe did not originally own
any part of Indiana, and was only permitted to occupy a part of the
territory. In fact, no considerable part of that tribe ever occupied
Indiana. except while on the war path. He was a cunning and brave
warrior, and an eloquent orator, and was very popular with the various
tribes in the Northwestern Territory. He visited the various tribes and
made speeches to them. In his speeches, he proclaimed that the treaties
for lands northwest of the Ohio River were not made with fairness, and
all of them should be considered void. That no single tribe was invested
with the power or authority to sell lands without the consent of the
other tribes; and that he and his brother, the Prophet, would resist all
further attempts of the whites to extend their settlbments into this
territory. These two famous Indians, by their persistent efforts and
wonderful influence, finally brought about a powerful confederation of
Indians, and the treaties were not made effectual until after the battle
of Tippecanoe, which occurred on the 7th day of November, 1811. The
Delawares, who at that time occupied the White River and White Water
Country, which included the territory embraced in Greene County, refused
to join Tecumseh's confederacy, and remained at peace with the whites.
Soon after the battle of Tippe canoe, the Indians commenced their
removal to the West, and the last band left Greene County in 1819. A few
years after that, a band of Indians on their way to the West camped for
a few days just above the mouth of Latta's Creek, on the west bank of
White River. The Piankeshaws were sent to Missouri and Kansas, and
finally all to Kansas. The number has grown smaller and smaller, as they
have continually met the encroachments of the lower order of whites,
with their handmaids of destruction—whisky and disease. In 1854, they
were confederated with the Weas, Peorias and Kaskaskias, and they all
numbered 259. In 1868, they numbered only 1'79. There has since been
attached to this confederation the Miamis, iNho went west of Indiana,
and at this. writing (1883), they are in the Indian Territory, and
number, all told, 208. In late years, the dawn of a brighter and better
era is upon them. They now own 52,000 acres of good land, and have 3,000
acres in cultivation. They live in good homes, and dress like civilized
people, and their children attend schools of their own. Eight of their
boys have come back to the land of their ancestors, and are now
attending college in Indiana. The Delawares, who were the last Indians
who occupied Greene County, have been uniformly more fortunate than the
Piankeshaws. Some of them are still in Kansas. In 1866, 1,000 Delawares
and Shawnees were incorporated with the Cherokees in the Indian
Territory, and are doing well. They are in an advanced state of
civilization, and are worth more per capita than any other tribe of
Indians. Their language is one of the best known of the Algonquin'
dialects. Tammany, whose name figures extensively with New York
politics, was a Delaware chief of the mythical period. There was an
early tradition among the Delawares that they were originally Western
Indians, and at a very early day emigrated to the East. At the first
settlement in the United States, they occupied the territory along the
Delaware River, from which they take their present name, and it was with
them that William Penn made his celebrated treaty by which he acquired
Pennsylvania. During the war of the rebellion the Delawares furnished
1'70 soldiers for the federal army, who proved brave and efficient
soldiers and scouts.
THE WORTHINGTON MOUNDS.
The remaining portion of this chapter was prepared by Prof. John Collett,
the eminent State Geologist, and published in his report of 1880. The
sketch is so complete and meritorious that the entire article is quoted,
with slight alterations to suit this volume.
The .mound was slightly elliptical, being 360 feet wide from north to
south, and from 360 to 390 feet long from east to west; the extreme
height of carried material at a point a little northeast of the center,
was nine feet six inches, sloping rapidly to the east, but with gradual
incline north, south and west. The carried material was a fine loam or
clayey earth, brought from a neighboring marsh one-quarter to a half
agile north, so that the distinction between the artificial mound and
the natural surface of clear flnviatile sand was easily apparent. This
material amounted to nearly 4,000 cubic yards of earth-1,800 wagon
loads; and as these people had none of the tools of our time, we may say
108,000 basketfuls. Allowing that these workmen or builders would travel
as far as an army under heavy marching orders, they would carry and
deposit about one-half a cubit, yard per day to each man, or 8,000 days
for one man. But considering that each man had to supply himself with
food and that he had to join in the dance and festivities common to
barbarous people on ceremonial occaaions, we may more safely estimate
nine basketfuls, or nine cubic feet as a day's work; consequently it
would require the labor of one man 12,000 days, or 200 persons full
sixty days. The outlook due east was up a valley piercing the eastern
bluff of White River, giving the sleepless priest, who guarded the ever
burning fire upon his altar, such opportunity of catching the first rays
of sunrise as was necessary in calling his people by chant and drum to
their morning devotion and worship of the sun—the fountain of life,
light and comfort.
A BURIAL VAULT.
Several years ago, IV. C. Andrews in preparing for the erection of the
old Franklin House, excavated part of the east side and top of the
mound. Near the central apex, he found an elliptical vault eight feet
long, five feet wide and three feet deep, surrounded by a sandstone wall
eighteen inches. thick, with a narrow entrance at the south end, and a
minor elliptical chamber separated by a wall at the north extremity. The
bottom was floored with thin slabs or flag-stones; it contained no bones
or other relics, but the interior contents, a " fat block" earth,
indicated the decomposed remains of a cover of black bituminous shale
from the roof of neighboring outcrops of Coal A. This vault was
evidently not connected with but intrusive upon the original work after
abandonment by the originators. It seems especially adapted for the
purpose of a temporary receiving vault for bodies of those dying between
the epochal national funerals. Such temporary vaults were noticed at
Fort Azatlan, in Sullivan County, and other places in this State. Its
location was invited by the circular depression at the chimney-top near
the apex of their predecessors' edifices. In 1878, the town authorities
of Worthington removed a considerable 'part from the north side of the
mound, discovering none of the ancient
sins, but exposing several intrusive Indian graves near the surface, but
on the completion, March, 1880, of the Terre Haute & Southeastern
Railroad to this point, it was necessary in making a junction with the
Indianapolis & Vincennes Railroad to fill up the abandoned bed of the
Wabash & Erie Canal along the tract of the latter road. This was done
under the direction of Calvin S. Taylor, by borrowing earth from the
mound. Much credit is due Mr. Taylor for carefully observing the
developments made for sacredly preserving the few relics found and for
measurements here reported.
ARRANGEMENT OF THE MOUND.
The following interior arrangements were observed: The surface soil bad
been stripped away to a depth of seven or eight inches, exposing a
subsoil of compact, fine sand, which constituted the floor of the mound
MFG. Near the center was a bed of ashes about ten inches deep, covering
an area of ten or twelve feet square, in which were roasted bones of
animals, spikes of deer horn, mussel and snail shells, charcoal and
fragments of earthen-ware pots, indicating the kitchen fire of a large
household. The disturbed nature of the earth above the fire-place, with
a quantity of flat stones reddened by fire, seemed to indicate a
chimney, or smoke flue, partly supported by rough masonry, which in the
course of time had fallen in; black spots, or columns of black mold at
the circumference of the mound and at the interior points showed that
trunks of trees had been utilized as posts to support the earthen roof,
which had entirely decayed. The floor of the building was covered with
fragments of broken pottery, with a few stone or bone implements of
household use. No warlike weapons were seen—it was a peaceful
agricultural people. The whole mound seemed to indicate the communal
home of a large family or tribe with a common roof, walls, fire, etc., a
mode of life characteristic of many primitive nations and races. Human
skeletons were found irregularly scattered near the circumference of a
circle, about sixty feet in diameter, having the ash pit for its center,
but more numerous near the eastern doorway. The bones were badly
decayed, and as a rule went to dust after exposure. They would represent
a possible fifteen or twenty individuals.
A PRE-HISTORIC MURDER.
At once the question arises, What changed this residence or home of a
tribe to a charnel house? A single circumstance throws a ray of light.
On the northwestern arc of the circular corridor, or area, was found the
skeleton of a man with household implements widely scattered about as if
in ordinary use; the back part of his skull was crushed in by a blow of
a large stone hammer from behind and below,or while reclining on his
right side, making an opening and indentation in the occipital re gion
two and one-half by three inches in area. A murder had been committed;
an unholy death had occurred beside the household altar, and, probably
by a law common to some American and Pacific Island peoples, the house
was thenceforward tabooed as unfit for occupation, and dedicated to the
dead. The remains of others were then brought from temporary graves, and
here deposited in the national " dead house " for their last sleep. The
articles found on the floor of the mound were:
1. Crania and human bones. 2. Ornamental vase. 3. Japanese image—head.
4. Japanese image—foot. 5. Bone whistle. 0. Copper ax. 7. Flint knives.
8. A smooth, symmetrical, oblong, spherical stone muller or pestle. 9.
Flint chips, by -abrasion showing use. 10. Bone implement.
CRANIAL MEASUREMENTS.
The skull was of the typical pyramidal form, characteristic of the early
Mound Builders, and gave the following measurements. Circumference from
eyebrow to base of occiput, 18.20 inches; frontal arc, from ear to ear,
10.10 inches; arc over top from ear to ear, 12.75 inches. The
well-closed sutures and worn teeth, as examined by Dr. Brouillette, of
Worthington, indicated his -age to have been fifty-five or sixty years,
and by measurement of the tibia, his height when living was only five
feet, four inches. The high' head showed an unreasoning man of great
firmness and energy, and the projecting lower jaw a strong flesh eater.
The cranium was abnormal or lop-sided, by reason of superior size of the
right over the left side, so that when erect the head would incline that
way, and as a rule he would sleep lying on that side, as was probably
the case when he was killed.
POTTERY, JAPANESE IMAGES, VASES, ETC.
The vase is ornamented by a peculiar fillet, with complementary pendant
curves in symmetrical design, and shows more skill than is usual in
Mound Builders' pottery. It is the most artistic design, accompanied by
regular form, seen by the writer, out of over 1,000 specimens, by him
examined, and seems to indicate skill of a higher order than the
careless efforts of an occasional workman. In other words, it exhibits
the skill of an habitual mechanic, trained by teachers as well as
practice. The Japanese head and foot were so peculiar as to awaken
doubts as to the genuineness of the find, hence an exhaustive inquiry
was made, not only of those immediately engaged in the
excavation, but of other citizens, calling in the aid of the well-known
and successful detective, Mr. K. Osborn. The testimony of all united as
to its authenticity. The Superintendent, C. S. Taylor, reports that it
was found by a boy, employed on the excavation about sixty feet
north-northwest from the hearthstone center, on the sand floor, eight
feet below the surface. When first removed from its bed, it was soaked
with the dampness of the earth and so softened that in brushing away the
adhering dirt the extremity of the nose- and ball of the right eye were
slightly abraded, as may be seen. The image was probably entire, but in
the bustle of work with a full force of men and teams, only the head and
one foot were preserved. The head is a striking picture, no artist could
conceive the image of an eagle or lion, and fix it in pictured art
without seeing or knowing of such animals. The physiognomy here given is
as distinct from other races as these animals are from other species.
The most inventive genius could not join the almond eyes, high cheek
bones, strong nose, pouting lips and flabby ears to an image without
seeing familiarly an original Japanese. Nor would he have done so unless
the figure awoke either ideas of beauty or respect for a superior form,
worthy qualities, as an ancestor, governor, teacher or necessary
protector. Mound pottery, as a rule, is rude, inartistic and composed of
a mixture of clay and coarsely powdered mussel shells. This image on the
other hand is an exact presentment of a certain type, and does not
contain in the interior fragments of shells; but, in addition to the
other points of superiority, has the exterior surface covered with a
well-defined coat of grayish-white clay, an art not usual in our ancient
potteries. All these facts seem to show that this image was the work of
an artist with more than self-acquired skill, and was the result of
generations of men, combining their experience from teacher to pupil,
from master to learner, and was borrowed from some older life center,
and this knowledge of the facial expression, it is suggested, could only
be borrowed from Japan or China. The recent emigration of a fleet of
canoes of Asiatic Esquimaux by Behring's Strait to Alaska on this
continent fully sustains this suggestion.
CHEMICAL CONSTITUENTS OF THE IDOL.
The material of the image was submitted. to Chemical Assistant Hurty for
qualitative analysis, and it was found to contain silicates of alumina,
soda and potassium, and sand humus and oxide of iron.If it was of modern
make, it would not have contained part of these ingredients, and if
imported from Asia would have contained the common kaolin of Eastern
Asia. But the analysis shows that the image was made up from common
swamp clay, and still -contained humus or organic matter, and the
coating was from the fire-clay of some adjacent coal bank, clearly
indicating that it was made of local materials, and therefore of local
manufacture.
COPPER IMPLEMENTS.
The copper ax is of the usual size and form discovered in the mounds. On
analysis, it was found to be composed of copper, with traces of iron and
carbon, but without alloy of phosphorus or tin. The analysis shows its
origin from the copper mines of Lake Superior, and indicates their line
of immigration by these mines to Indiana. The other articles mentioned
were the household implements, common about the kitchen fires of this
race.
|